The Swiss Refugee Council (OSAR) criticized the Swiss Federal Council’s decision to limit the scope of the S protection status for Ukrainian refugees.
While OSAR welcomed the extension of this status until March 2027, it condemned the classification of seven Ukrainian regions as “safe,” calling the move politically motivated and detached from on-the-ground realities.
According to OSAR, security conditions across Ukraine remain unstable, making any reliable distinction between safe and unsafe areas impossible.
The organization pointed out that the European Union makes no such differentiation and emphasized that protection should only be lifted once the war has ended, a peace agreement has been signed, and international bodies can ensure safety.
OSAR also noted that Russia’s intensified drone and missile attacks since 2024–2025, including in the supposedly “safe” regions, make the new restrictions especially unrealistic. The group criticized the decision to apply the new rules retroactively to refugees whose applications are still pending and argued they should only apply to those filed after 1 November 2025.
While OSAR welcomed the continued protection program, it opposed new restrictions on freedom of movement, specifically, reducing the permitted stay in Ukraine for S-status holders from 15 days per quarter to 15 days per half-year, saying such measures hinder family connections and voluntary return efforts.